# Red Herring and Whataboutism

> Five ways to dodge a point instead of answering it. A side issue, a finger pointed back, a tug at feelings, a big name and a big crowd.

**Course:** [Critical Thinking](https://learn.benibix.com/learn/general-critical-thinking)  
**Time:** 12 min

**After this lesson you can:**

- Spot a red herring and pull the talk back
- Answer whataboutism without taking the bait
- Tell a fair use of experts from an appeal to authority

## How do people dodge a question without answering it?

Some fallacies do not twist the claim. They swerve around it. A red herring brings up a side issue so the real question gets dropped. Whataboutism points at someone else's fault. Appeals to emotion, to authority and to popularity each swap the evidence for something else. In all five, the point is never met.

A red herring can be hard to spot because the side issue is often true and interesting. Asked why prices rose, a firm talks about the jobs it created. The jobs may be real. The question was about prices. The fix is to say so, kindly, and ask again.

Whataboutism answers blame with blame. You were late again. Well, what about the time you forgot my birthday? Even if both are true, the second does not excuse the first. Two faults do not cancel out. Each can be dealt with on its own.

An appeal to emotion tries to win with fear, pity or anger instead of reasons. Feelings are not the problem. A sad story can be true and can matter. The fallacy is when the feeling is offered in place of evidence, and the evidence is missing.

An appeal to authority uses a big name as the proof. A famous actor says a diet works. But fame is not proof, and an actor is not an expert in food. Trusting experts is reasonable when they speak in their own field and most of them agree.

An appeal to popularity says a claim is true because many people believe it. Millions use this remedy, so it must work. Most people once thought the sun went round the Earth. How many people believe a thing tells you about people, not about the thing.

One habit catches all five. When the reply ends, ask what it said about the original claim. If the honest answer is nothing, the point was dodged. You do not need to name the fallacy out loud. Just bring the talk back to the question.

## Five ways to dodge the point

| Fallacy | What it offers instead | A typical line |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Red herring | A side issue | Look at all the jobs we made |
| Whataboutism | Someone else's fault | What about when you did it? |
| Appeal to emotion | Fear, pity or anger | Think of the children |
| Appeal to authority | A famous name | A star swears by it |
| Appeal to popularity | A big crowd | Millions can't be wrong |

![Five panels, each with an arrow that should hit the claim but goes somewhere else. Red herring: the arrow swerves to a fish on a side path. Whataboutism: the arrow turns back at the person asking. Appeal to emotion: the arrow hits a crying face. Appeal to authority: the arrow hits a famous person's badge. Appeal to popularity: the arrow hits a big crowd.](https://learn.benibix.com/diagrams/gen6-off-topic-fallacies.svg)

### Example: Nina interviews a mayor

Nina, a local reporter, asks the mayor why the new bridge is two years late and $40 million over budget. He talks about the city's new parks.

She asks again. He says the last mayor's road was worse. Nina writes that the mayor gave no reason for the delay, and quotes both dodges.

**Words in this lesson:** [Red Herring](https://learn.benibix.com/term/general/red-herring), [Whataboutism](https://learn.benibix.com/term/general/whataboutism), [Appeal to Emotion](https://learn.benibix.com/term/general/appeal-to-emotion), [Appeal to Authority](https://learn.benibix.com/term/general/appeal-to-authority), [Appeal to Popularity](https://learn.benibix.com/term/general/appeal-to-popularity)

**Question:** When is it fair to rely on what an expert says?

**Answer:** When they speak in their own field and most experts agree. Expert views are good evidence inside their field, most of all when experts agree. Fame, or a strong opinion, is not.

---

Source: https://learn.benibix.com/learn/general-critical-thinking/red-herring-and-whataboutism
Author: Behnia Zarei (a developer in Vienna, Austria, who builds and teaches data, AI and business intelligence at BENIBIX)
Publisher: BENIBIX Learn (https://learn.benibix.com/)
Last updated: 2026-11-19
Licence: CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Quote freely with attribution.
