Agent Reflection vs Evaluator-Optimizer Loop
People think reflection and an evaluator-optimizer loop are the same thing, and they are not. In reflection, one model reads its own work and fixes it. In the loop, the job is split in two. One model writes, and a second model judges it by clear rules. A second judge can catch what the writer keeps missing.
Agent Reflection
When an AI agent reviews its own work and fixes what it finds.
Agent reflection is when an AI agent checks its own work and fixes it before it moves on. It writes a draft or takes a step, then reads the result with fresh eyes. It asks what is wrong or missing, and writes a better version. Real feedback helps most, such as a failed test or an error message. Without that, a model can miss its own mistakes, so reflection works best when it can check against facts.
Evaluator-Optimizer Loop
One model makes a draft and a second one judges it. They repeat until it passes.
An evaluator-optimizer loop is a pattern where one model makes something and another model judges it. The first model writes a draft. The second checks it against clear rules and sends back notes. The first model uses the notes to write a better draft. They repeat this until the judge is happy or a set number of rounds runs out.
In one line
- Agent Reflection
- When an AI agent reviews its own work and fixes what it finds.
- Evaluator-Optimizer Loop
- One model makes a draft and a second one judges it. They repeat until it passes.