Card Sorting vs Tree Testing
People think card sorting and tree testing are the same test, and they are not. In card sorting, people put topics into groups to help you build a menu. In a tree test, people try to find things in a menu you already built. Sort first to shape it, then tree test to check it.
Card Sorting
Users sort topics on cards into groups. It shows how they expect things to be organized.
Card sorting is a research method where users group topics written on cards. In an open sort, users make and name their own groups. In a closed sort, they put cards into groups the team already chose. The results show how people expect content to be organized and what they would call each group. It is a main input to information architecture.
Tree Testing
A test of a site's menu words. People use a plain text menu with no design.
Tree testing checks whether people can find things in a menu structure. They see only a plain text list of menu labels, with no design at all. They are given a task, like find the return policy, and click down through the levels. The test records where they go and where they get lost. It tests the labels and the grouping, before any screen is drawn.
In one line
- Card Sorting
- Users sort topics on cards into groups. It shows how they expect things to be organized.
- Tree Testing
- A test of a site's menu words. People use a plain text menu with no design.