Choice Overload vs Hick's Law
People think choice overload is just Hick's Law, and it is not. Hick's Law says each extra option makes a choice take a bit longer. Choice overload says too many options can stop people from choosing at all. One is about speed. The other is about walking away.
Choice Overload
Too many choices make people stop. Some pick nothing at all.
Choice overload is when too many options make people stuck or unhappy, or make them pick nothing. Each extra option adds more to compare. Past a point, people put off the choice or walk away. Fewer, clearer options often lead to more decisions, not fewer. Good defaults and filters help when a long list cannot be avoided.
Hick's Law
The more choices there are, the longer it takes to pick one.
Hick's law says the time it takes to make a choice grows with the number of options. It comes from studies by William Hick and Ray Hyman in the early 1950s. The time grows more slowly than the count, because people can rule out groups of options at once. In design, it means fewer and well-grouped choices lead to faster decisions.
time = a + b × log2(n + 1)In one line
- Choice Overload
- Too many choices make people stop. Some pick nothing at all.
- Hick's Law
- The more choices there are, the longer it takes to pick one.