Cognitive Walkthrough vs Heuristic Evaluation
People think a cognitive walkthrough is a heuristic evaluation, and it is not. Both are reviews done by a team, with no real users. A heuristic evaluation checks the whole design against a list of rules. A cognitive walkthrough follows one task, step by step. The team plays a brand-new user and asks four questions at each step. That finds where a beginner gets lost.
Cognitive Walkthrough
A team steps through a task as a new user would. They ask four questions at each step.
A cognitive walkthrough is a review where a team steps through a task as a brand-new user would. No real users take part. At each step, the team asks four questions about that new user. Will they try the right thing, spot the control, know what it does, and see that it worked? Each no marks a place where a new user may get lost.
Heuristic Evaluation
A few experts check a design. They use a short list of rules.
In a heuristic evaluation, a few experts check a design against a list of known rules of thumb for easy use. The best known list is Jakob Nielsen's ten rules. Two of them are: tell users what is going on, and help them fix their mistakes. Each expert works alone, then they combine what they found. It is fast and cheap, but it does not replace tests with real users.
In one line
- Cognitive Walkthrough
- A team steps through a task as a new user would. They ask four questions at each step.
- Heuristic Evaluation
- A few experts check a design. They use a short list of rules.