Skip to content
BENIBIX Learn

DCF vs Comparable Company Analysis

People think a DCF and comparables are two ways to get the same answer, and they often disagree. A DCF looks inside the firm, at the cash it will make. Comparables look around, at what similar firms sell for today. A DCF can miss the mood of the market. Comparables can copy the market's mistakes. Good valuers do both and explain the gap.

Business🏦 Corporate Finance

Discounted Cash Flow (DCF)

Future cash, each year shrunk to its worth today, then added up. That sum is the value.

Discounted cash flow is a way to value a firm or a project from the cash it will make. First you forecast the cash for each future year. Then you shrink each year's cash back to today's money, using a discount rate. Cash further away shrinks more. The total of all those shrunk amounts is the value today.

Example
A machine will bring in $100 a year for five years. At a 10% discount rate, those years are worth $91, $83, $75, $68 and $62 today, or $379 in all.
Formula
Value = sum of Cash Flow in year t / (1 + r)^t, where r is the discount rate
Why it matters
It values a thing by what it will earn, not by what people say it is worth. Net present value and most company values start from it.
Full entry
Business🏦 Corporate Finance

Comparable Company Analysis

Finding a firm's value by checking what firms like it are worth.

Comparable company analysis values a firm by looking at similar firms. You pick a group of firms in the same trade and about the same size. You work out the multiples they sell at. Then you apply the middle multiple to your firm's own numbers. The answer is what the market would likely pay.

Example
Jack values a bike maker. Four similar firms sell at 8 to 12 times their profit. He uses 10 times and gets $30 million.
Why it matters
It ties a value to real prices people pay today. That makes it easy to explain and hard to argue with.
Full entry

In one line

Discounted Cash Flow (DCF)
Future cash, each year shrunk to its worth today, then added up. That sum is the value.
Comparable Company Analysis
Finding a firm's value by checking what firms like it are worth.