Design Review vs Design Critique
A critique is open feedback to make a design better. A review checks it against the goals and ends in a decision.
Design Review
A meeting that checks a design against its goals. It ends in a decision to go on, change or stop.
A design review checks a design against its goals. People from design, product and building look at it together. They ask if it solves the problem, fits the system and can be built. Unlike a critique, a review ends with a decision: go ahead, change it, or stop. Teams often hold one at each big step of a project.
Design Critique
A meeting to judge work that is not done yet. It is judged by its goal, not by taste.
A design critique is a meeting where people give feedback on work in progress. The designer shows the work and says what it is meant to do. Others judge it against that goal, not their own taste. Good feedback names a problem and why it matters. The designer then decides what to change.
In one line
- Design Review
- A meeting that checks a design against its goals. It ends in a decision to go on, change or stop.
- Design Critique
- A meeting to judge work that is not done yet. It is judged by its goal, not by taste.