Distributive vs Integrative Negotiation
People think win-win means splitting the difference, and it does not. Distributive talks fight over one fixed pie, so one side's gain is the other's loss. Integrative talks trade across several issues to make the pie bigger first. Splitting down the middle is still a fixed pie.
Distributive Negotiation
A deal over one fixed thing, so one side's gain is the other's loss.
Distributive negotiation is a deal over one fixed thing, most often money. What one side gains, the other side loses. Buying a used car is the classic case. Each side tries to claim as much of the value as it can. Tactics like a strong first offer and slow concessions matter most here.
Integrative Negotiation
A deal where both sides grow the value first, then share it.
Integrative negotiation is a deal where both sides look for ways to make the whole pie bigger before they split it. It works when there is more than one issue on the table. Each side cares about some issues more than others. So they trade: each gives up what it values less to get what it values more. Both can end up better off than a simple split.
In one line
- Distributive Negotiation
- A deal over one fixed thing, so one side's gain is the other's loss.
- Integrative Negotiation
- A deal where both sides grow the value first, then share it.