Fair Use vs Text and Data Mining Exception
People think the EU's data mining rule is Europe's version of fair use, and it is not. Fair use is a US rule where a court weighs four factors, case by case. The EU rule is a fixed exception for copying to find patterns. Anyone may use it, unless the owner opts out in a form a machine can read. A fair use win in the US says nothing about the EU.
Fair Use
A US rule that lets you use a work without asking. A court decides if it is fair.
Fair use is a rule in US copyright law that lets people use a work without asking, in some cases. A court decides each case by weighing four things. First, why the work is used, and whether the new use adds something new. Second and third, what kind of work it is and how much was taken. Fourth, whether the new use hurts the market for the original. Reviews, news, teaching and parody often pass, but no use is fair by default.
Text and Data Mining (TDM)
A computer copies lots of text to find patterns. EU law allows it, with limits.
Text and data mining is when a computer reads huge amounts of text or data to find patterns. In EU copyright law, it is also a rule that lets you copy for this without asking. Research bodies may mine any work they can lawfully reach, for research. Anyone else may too, unless the owner has said no in a way a machine can read. AI makers lean on it to train models on the web. The EU AI Act says model makers must respect those refusals.
In one line
- Fair Use
- A US rule that lets you use a work without asking. A court decides if it is fair.
- Text and Data Mining (TDM)
- A computer copies lots of text to find patterns. EU law allows it, with limits.
These live in different corners of the glossary (Business and AI), which is exactly why they get confused.