First-Price vs Second-Price Auction
People think the winner of an ad auction always pays what it bid, and that is not so. In a first-price auction, it does. In a second-price auction, the winner pays one cent more than the next best bid. If the bids are 4 euros and 3 euros, the winner pays 3.01. Most programmatic auctions now use first price.
First-Price Auction
The top bid wins, and the winner pays its own bid.
In a first-price auction, the highest bid wins and the winner pays exactly what it bid. Most programmatic ad auctions now work this way. It is simple, and the seller sees the true price. But buyers can overpay if they bid far above everyone else. So buying software uses bid shading, which lowers each bid toward what it thinks will just win.
Second-Price Auction
The top bid wins. It pays just a little more than the next bid.
In a second-price auction, the highest bid still wins, but the winner pays just above the second-highest bid. If the top bid is 4 euros and the next is 3, the winner pays 3 euros and 1 cent. This lets buyers bid what a view is really worth without paying too much. Programmatic ads mostly used it until the late 2010s. Search ad auctions have long used a version of it.
In one line
- First-Price Auction
- The top bid wins, and the winner pays its own bid.
- Second-Price Auction
- The top bid wins. It pays just a little more than the next bid.