Indirect Competitor vs Substitute Product
People mix up these two kinds of rival, and they are not the same. An indirect rival sells a different thing for the same need. It is often in your own trade, like a bakery that sells coffee. A substitute comes from a whole other industry, like tea made at home. Both take buyers away, but they need different answers.
Indirect Competitor
A rival with a different thing to sell. It meets the same need as yours.
An indirect competitor sells a different product that meets the same need. A coffee shop and a bakery both sell a morning treat. A train and a plane both get you to another city. The products look different, but the customer chooses between them. These rivals are easy to miss because they do not look like you.
Substitute Product
A thing from a whole other field. Buyers can use it in place of yours.
A substitute is a product from another industry that a buyer can use instead of yours. Tea is a substitute for coffee. A video call is a substitute for a plane trip to a meeting. When substitutes are cheap and easy, you cannot raise your price much. Porter's five forces counts them as one of the five pressures on profit.
In one line
- Indirect Competitor
- A rival with a different thing to sell. It meets the same need as yours.
- Substitute Product
- A thing from a whole other field. Buyers can use it in place of yours.