RICE Scoring vs Kano Model
People think RICE and the Kano model are two ways to get the same score, and they are not. RICE ranks ideas by numbers: how many people, how much help, how sure you are, and how much work. The Kano model sorts features by how customers feel about them: a must, more is better, or a nice surprise. Kano tells you what kind of feature it is. RICE tells you what to build first.
RICE Scoring
Rank ideas by reach, impact and how sure you are. Then divide by effort.
RICE scoring ranks product ideas with four numbers. Reach is how many people it touches in a set time, like a quarter. Impact is how much it helps each one, often on a scale from 0.25 to 3. Confidence is how sure you are, as a percentage. Effort is the work needed, in person-months. Multiply the first three, divide by effort, and the highest score goes first.
RICE score = Reach × Impact × Confidence ÷ EffortKano Model
Some features are a must. Some get better the more you add. Some are a nice surprise.
The Kano model sorts features by how they make customers feel. Basic features are expected, so having them earns no praise, but missing them makes people angry. Performance features make people happier the better they get, like speed. Delighters are surprises people did not ask for but love. Some features make no difference at all. Noriaki Kano described the model in 1984.
In one line
- RICE Scoring
- Rank ideas by reach, impact and how sure you are. Then divide by effort.
- Kano Model
- Some features are a must. Some get better the more you add. Some are a nice surprise.