Theory X and Theory Y vs Theory Z
People think Theory Z is McGregor's third theory, and it is not. Douglas McGregor wrote Theory X and Theory Y in 1960. They are two beliefs a boss can hold about workers. William Ouchi wrote Theory Z in 1981. It is a way to run a whole firm, mixing US and Japanese habits.
Theory X and Theory Y
Two views of workers: they must be pushed (X), or they want to do well (Y).
Theory X and Theory Y are two views a manager can hold about people at work. Theory X says people dislike work and must be watched, pushed and controlled. Theory Y says people can enjoy work, take on duties and use their own ideas. Each view tends to come true, because staff act the way they are treated. The idea comes from Douglas McGregor, a professor at MIT.
Theory Z
A mix of Japanese and American ways to run a firm. Jobs last long, big choices are shared, and staff are trusted.
Theory Z is a way of managing that mixes Japanese and American habits. William Ouchi set it out in a 1981 book, when Japanese firms were winning in many markets. A Theory Z firm keeps people for a long time. It makes big choices by group agreement and trusts staff more than rules. Each person still owns their own work. Promotion is slow, and people learn many parts of the firm.
In one line
- Theory X and Theory Y
- Two views of workers: they must be pushed (X), or they want to do well (Y).
- Theory Z
- A mix of Japanese and American ways to run a firm. Jobs last long, big choices are shared, and staff are trusted.