Skip to content
BENIBIX Learn

Transfer Impact Assessment vs DPIA

People think a transfer check is the same as a DPIA, and it is not. A DPIA asks what a new use of data could do to the people in it. A transfer impact assessment asks one narrower thing. Will the laws of another country undo the safeguards on data sent there? A project that sends data abroad may need both.

Data🔒 Data Privacy

Transfer Impact Assessment (TIA)

A check of another country's laws. It asks if data sent there stays safe.

A transfer impact assessment checks whether data sent outside the EU will really stay safe. It looks at the laws of the country the data goes to, such as what its government can demand. The need for it came from the EU's top court, in the Schrems II case of July 2020. The standard contractual clauses now ask both sides to do it and write it down. If the risk is too high, the firms add extra steps, such as encryption with keys kept in the EU. If nothing fixes it, the data must not go.

Example
A firm in Vienna plans to store staff files with a host in a country with broad spying laws. Its check finds the risk too high, so it encrypts the files and keeps the keys in the EU.
Why it matters
Signing contract clauses is not enough on its own. Regulators expect to see this check when they look at a transfer.
Full entry
Data🔒 Data Privacy

Data Protection Impact Assessment (DPIA)

A risk check you write first. Then a risky data use may start.

A data protection impact assessment is a written risk check before a new use of personal data. Article 35 of the GDPR asks for one when a use is likely to be high risk for people. Tracking people on a large scale, scoring them or using health data are examples. The check describes the use and asks if it is really needed. Then it lists the risks and the steps that cut them. If a high risk is left, the firm must ask the watchdog before it starts.

Example
A gym wants members to get in with a face scan. Its DPIA flags face data as sensitive. So the gym keeps a card as another way in, and deletes the scans of anyone who leaves.
Why it matters
It finds the harm on paper, while the plan can still change. Skipping a required one can bring a fine even if nothing goes wrong.
Full entry

In one line

Transfer Impact Assessment (TIA)
A check of another country's laws. It asks if data sent there stays safe.
Data Protection Impact Assessment (DPIA)
A risk check you write first. Then a risky data use may start.