Usability Testing vs Heuristic Evaluation
In a usability test, real users try real tasks while you watch. In the other, a few experts check the design against a list of rules. Only the test shows where real users trip.
Usability Testing
Watching real people try real tasks. You see where they get stuck.
Usability testing is watching real people try to do real tasks with a product or prototype. A host gives a task, like buy a train ticket, and watches without helping. Users are often asked to think aloud. Small rounds of about five users find many of the biggest problems. The team fixes them and tests again. It can be done in person or over a video call.
Heuristic Evaluation
A few experts check a design. They use a short list of rules.
In a heuristic evaluation, a few experts check a design against a list of known rules of thumb for easy use. The best known list is Jakob Nielsen's ten rules. Two of them are: tell users what is going on, and help them fix their mistakes. Each expert works alone, then they combine what they found. It is fast and cheap, but it does not replace tests with real users.
In one line
- Usability Testing
- Watching real people try real tasks. You see where they get stuck.
- Heuristic Evaluation
- A few experts check a design. They use a short list of rules.