Skip to content
BENIBIX Learn

Appeal to Authority

General🤔 Critical ThinkingErrors in Reasoning

Also known as Argument from Authority, Argumentum ad Verecundiam, False Authority

A big name is used as the proof, not the facts.

Think of it like

It is like trusting a football star about your car's brakes. He is famous, but not for brakes.

Example

A film star says a diet cures tiredness. Lucy notes he is not a doctor. She looks for what studies of the diet found.

Why it matters

Ads and posts lean on famous faces because they work. Checking a person's field and the evidence keeps the name from doing the thinking.

Definition

An appeal to authority is using someone's fame or rank as the proof that a claim is true. It goes wrong when the person is not an expert in the topic. It also goes wrong when one name is used to cancel what most experts agree on. Trusting real experts in their own field is sensible, not a fallacy. The question is whether the evidence holds, not only who said it.
Fourth panel: the arrow hits a star's badge, and not the proof.

Common mistake

Rejecting all expert advice as this fallacy. Leaning on experts in their own field is how most of us learn.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Wrong field. Fame in one area is not skill in another.
  2. 2
    One against many. One name does not beat the wider view.
  3. 3
    Evidence first. Ask what the proof is, not just who said it.

Learn it properly