Skip to content
BENIBIX Learn

Red Herring

General🤔 Critical ThinkingErrors in Reasoning

Also known as Red Herring Fallacy, Changing the Subject

A side point that pulls a talk away from the real question.

Think of it like

It is like you point at a bird in the sky. Then you grab the last bit of cake.

Example

A reporter asks a mayor why the bus fares went up. The mayor talks for five minutes about the new park. The fare question is never answered.

Why it matters

It lets a hard question go unanswered while the talk feels busy. Bringing the talk back is often all it takes.

Definition

A red herring is a point that pulls attention away from the real question. It may be true and even interesting, but it does not answer what was asked. The talk drifts to the new topic, and the first question is dropped. It can be used on purpose or by accident. The name comes from a smelly fish said to throw dogs off a trail.
First panel: the arrow swerves off to a fish on a side path.

Common mistake

Following the new topic because it is interesting. Note it, then return to the first question.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Off the point. It does not answer what was asked.
  2. 2
    Drift away. The real question gets dropped.
  3. 3
    Steer back. Repeat the first question.

Learn it properly