Prisoner's Dilemma in Business
Level 3 Β· When markets go wrong
Why two firms can both lose by putting themselves first. The prisoner's dilemma, and how playing the same game again changes the answer.
Course contentsLesson 7 of 11
Level 2 Β· Markets and prices
Level 3 Β· When markets go wrong
Level 4 Β· The whole economy
After this lesson you can
- Read a payoff grid for two players
- Explain why both sides cut in a one-off game
- Name two ways to change the game so cutting stops paying
12 mincovers 2 glossary entries
Worth reading first: Monopoly and Oligopoly
Why two firms can both lose by acting in their own interest
Game theory studies choices where your best move depends on what others do. Its best-known case is the prisoner's dilemma. Two firms each earn 10 if both keep prices high. If one cuts, it earns 15 and the other earns 2. If both cut, each earns 5. Acting alone, both cut and both lose.
Look at it from Firm A's side. If B keeps its price high, A earns more by cutting: 15 instead of 10. If B cuts, A still does better by cutting: 5 instead of 2. Whatever B does, cutting looks better. B reasons the same way. So both cut and land on 5 each, when 10 was on the table.
A game, in this sense, is any case with players, choices and payoffs. The field was set out in a book in 1944. It is now used for pricing, auctions and bargaining. It asks what each player should do when all of them are thinking ahead.
The trap is worst when the game is played once. Most business games repeat. Two shops on the same street set prices every week for years. If one cuts, the other can cut back next week. Knowing that, both have a reason to keep prices steady. Playing again and again makes trust worth something.
A simple plan works well when the game repeats. Start by playing fair, then copy whatever the other side did last time. It rewards a good move at once, punishes a bad one at once, and forgives. In computer contests run around 1980, this plan beat far cleverer ones.
The same shape turns up all over business. Two firms spend heavily on ads to steal each other's buyers. Countries raise taxes on each other's goods. Team members each hold back effort on a shared project. In each case, every side does what seems smart, and all of them end up worse off.
The usual mistake is thinking the answer is to trust the other side. The better answer is to change the game. Long contracts, promises to match any lower price, and shared industry rules all change the payoffs. When cutting no longer pays, nobody needs to be trusted.
Worked example
Two airlines on one route
Two airlines fly the same route. Each can spend $2 million a year on ads, or nothing. If both advertise, they split the passengers as before and each is $2 million poorer.
If only one spent, it would win people from the other. So both keep paying, year after year, for ads that mostly cancel out.
The words for this lesson2
Check yourself
In a one-off prisoner's dilemma, why do both firms cut their prices?
Finished this lesson?
Marking it complete also marks its 2 glossary entries learned, which updates your roadmap and your saved page. 0 are already marked.