Fair Use and EU Copyright
Level 2 Β· Intellectual property
When you can use someone else's work without asking. US fair use and its four factors, Austria's list of free uses, and the EU's rules on data mining.
Course contentsLesson 4 of 8
Level 1 Β· Business structures
Level 2 Β· Intellectual property
Level 3 Β· Contracts
Level 4 Β· Selling and liability
After this lesson you can
- Name the four fair use factors
- Explain why fair use is a defence, not a permission
- Say when EU law lets anyone mine text and data
13 mincovers 3 glossary entries
Worth reading first: Intellectual Property Types
When you can use someone else's work without asking
Copyright has limits, and they differ by country. In the US, fair use lets you use a work without asking if a court finds the use fair, judged on four factors. The EU has no general fair use. It lists exact cases instead, and its 2019 copyright directive added rules for mining text and data, which AI training relies on.
A US court weighs four things. Why is it used: does it add something new, like a review or a parody? What kind of work is it: plain facts or a novel? How much was taken: a few lines or the heart of it? And does it harm sales of the original? No single factor decides.
Fair use is a defence, not a permission slip. You only find out it was fair if someone sues and a judge agrees. Quoting two lines of a book in a review is usually safe. Copying a whole chapter for a course is usually not. In between, people ask, pay for a licence, or take a known risk.
Most of Europe works from a list. Austria's copyright act, the UrhG, protects a work for the author's life plus 70 years. It names the cases where you may use a work freely, such as quoting with credit or a private copy. If your use is not on the list, you need permission, however fair it seems.
The EU's 2019 copyright directive brought those lists up to date for the internet. It made sites that host uploads take more care over copyright. It also set two rules on mining text and data. Mining means using software to read huge amounts of content and find patterns in it.
Research bodies may mine any work they can lawfully reach. Everyone else may mine too, unless the owner has said no in a form a machine can read. A line in a site's settings file is one way. That is why many sites now post rules aimed at the bots that gather data for AI.
The common mistake is assuming US fair use applies everywhere. A blog run from Vienna is judged under Austrian law. A use that would be fair in New York may simply be copying there. Check which country's law applies before you rely on any exception.
Worked example
The same clip in two countries
A teacher in the US puts 20 seconds of a film into a lesson video to discuss its camera work. That is likely fair use. It adds comment, uses a small part, and replaces no ticket sales.
A teacher in Austria does the same. There is no general fair use there, so she checks the UrhG's list of allowed uses for teaching before she posts it.
The words for this lesson3
Check yourself
Which of these is true of fair use in the US?
Finished this lesson?
Marking it complete also marks its 3 glossary entries learned, which updates your roadmap and your saved page. 0 are already marked.