Expert UX Reviews
Level 2 · Finding out from users
How experts can find problems with no users in the room. Checking against rules, stepping through a task, and a full check of a live product.
Course contentsLesson 9 of 21
Level 1 · What UX is
Level 2 · Finding out from users
Level 3 · Making sense of research
Level 4 · Designing the interaction
After this lesson you can
- Run a heuristic evaluation
- Ask the four walkthrough questions
- Break a task into small steps
12 mincovers 4 glossary entries
Worth reading first: Eye Tracking and Recordings
How experts find problems without users
Some problems can be found without any users. In a heuristic evaluation, a few experts check a design against a short list of rules. The best known list has 10 rules, such as show what is going on and let people undo. One expert finds about a third of the problems. Five find about three quarters.
The rules are broad on purpose. Speak the user's words, not the system's. Keep things the same across screens. Prevent errors before they happen. Each expert works alone first, then they merge their lists, because people spot very different things.
Task analysis breaks a user's job into small steps. Pay a bill splits into log in, pick who to pay and send. Each of those splits again. Laid out like a tree, it shows how many steps there really are, and which ones are likely to trip people up.
A cognitive walkthrough steps through a task as a brand new user would. At each step the team asks four questions. Will they try to do this? Will they see the control? Will they know it does what they want? Will they see that it worked? A no is a problem.
A UX audit is the big version. Someone checks a whole live product, using rules, data and recordings. It ends in a ranked list of fixes, worst first. A hidden delivery cost that loses sales sits at the top. Small text that is hard to read sits lower.
Expert reviews are fast and cheap. They are also guesses. An expert is not your user, and will miss problems that come from your users' world. Use reviews to clear out the obvious problems, so that tests with real people find the deep ones.
The common slip is to list problems with no ranking. A list of 60 issues, all the same size, gets nothing fixed. Rank each one by how often it hits and how badly. The top five get done.
Four expert reviews
| Review | What experts do | What comes out |
|---|---|---|
| Heuristic evaluation | Check screens against 10 rules | A list of rule breaks |
| Task analysis | Split a job into small steps | A tree of steps |
| Cognitive walkthrough | Ask four questions at each step | The step a new user fails |
| UX audit | Check the whole live product | A ranked list of fixes |
Worked example
Three experts check a sign-up form
Three designers each checked a 12 field sign-up form alone, then merged their notes. Together they found 14 problems, and only 3 were on every list.
Ranked by harm, the top one was no way to see the password. Fixing the top 4 took two days.
The words for this lesson4
Check yourself
Why should each expert check the design alone first?
Finished this lesson?
Marking it complete also marks its 4 glossary entries learned, which updates your roadmap and your saved page. 0 are already marked.