Index Funds vs ETFs
Level 4 · Investing
How a fund pools many people's money. Why funds that copy an index beat most stock pickers. Why a 1 percent fee can cost a quarter of your savings.
Course contentsLesson 11 of 12
Level 1 · Budgets and saving
Level 2 · Interest
Level 3 · Debt and credit
Level 4 · Investing
Level 5 · Retirement
After this lesson you can
- Tell a mutual fund, an index fund and an ETF apart
- Work out what a fee costs over 30 years
- Explain dollar-cost averaging
12 mincovers 6 glossary entries
Worth reading first: Stocks, Bonds and Funds
What is the difference between an index fund and an ETF?
A fund pools money from many people and buys many things with it. An index fund copies a stock market index, such as the 500 large US companies in the S&P 500, instead of picking winners. An ETF is a fund you buy and sell on a stock exchange during the day, like a share. Many ETFs are also index funds.
A mutual fund is the older kind. It is priced once a day, after the market closes, and you buy from the fund company. An ETF trades all day at a price that moves. For someone saving every month and holding for years, the difference is small.
The bigger question is whether a fund copies an index or tries to beat it. Funds run by stock pickers charge more. Over 15 years, most of them do worse than the index they try to beat. Paying more for a worse result is a poor trade.
The expense ratio is what a fund costs you each year, as a share of your money in it. It sounds tiny. Put 10,000 in a fund that grows 7 percent a year before fees. After 30 years, a 0.1 percent fee leaves about 74,000. A 1 percent fee leaves about 57,000.
Dollar-cost averaging means putting the same amount in at set times, whatever the price. If 100 goes in each month while the price moves from 10 to 5 to 10, you buy 10, then 20, then 10 shares. You bought more when it was cheap, without having to guess when that was.
It also takes the fear out of timing. Nobody reliably knows when the market will rise or fall. A fixed amount each month, often taken straight from pay, means you never have to decide.
The common mistake is to chase last year's best fund. Funds that top the chart one year rarely stay there. A cheap, broad index fund, added to every month and left alone, beats most of the clever choices.
Three kinds of fund
| Fund | How it is bought | What it holds |
|---|---|---|
| Mutual fund | From the fund company, priced once a day | Picked by a manager, or an index |
| Index fund | As a mutual fund or as an ETF | Everything in an index |
| Exchange-traded fund | On a stock exchange, all day | Often an index, sometimes picked |
Worked example
Sam picks a fund
Sam's bank offers him a fund picked by a manager, with a 1.5 percent fee. An index fund that tracks the whole market costs 0.05 percent.
He picks the index fund and sets 150 a month to go in on payday. He does not check the price for months at a time.
The words for this lesson6
Check yourself
Over 15 years, how do most funds run by stock pickers do against their index?
Finished this lesson?
Marking it complete also marks its 6 glossary entries learned, which updates your roadmap and your saved page. 0 are already marked.