Double Jeopardy Law
Level 4 · How brands grow
Why small brands have fewer buyers, and less loyal ones too. What that means for growth, and why points schemes rarely make a small brand big.
Course contentsLesson 7 of 8
Level 1 · What marketing is
Level 2 · Where a business starts
Level 3 · Who buys, and why
Level 4 · How brands grow
After this lesson you can
- State the double jeopardy law
- Explain why small brands get less loyalty
- Say where a brand's growth comes from
11 mincovers 1 glossary entries
Worth reading first: Customer Value vs Satisfaction
Why small brands have fewer and less loyal buyers
The double jeopardy law says small brands lose twice. They have far fewer buyers than big brands, and those buyers are also a little less loyal. The pattern was first spotted in the 1960s. It has been found again in soap, petrol, banks, cars and TV channels.
Take two brands in one market, one with ten times the sales of the other. Most of that gap is the number of buyers. The big brand is simply bought by many more people. Its buyers also buy it a little more often. The small brand is behind on both, which is the double hit.
The surprise is the second part. Many people expect small brands to have a few passionate fans. Some do, like a local craft beer. But across most markets, the data shows the reverse. The buyers of small brands are slightly less loyal, not more.
The reason is simple. A small brand is less known and harder to find. So even its own buyers often see a bigger brand first and buy that one instead. Their loyalty is not lower because they like it less. It is lower because the brand is in front of them less often.
This changes where growth comes from. A brand cannot grow much by making its current buyers more loyal, because loyalty moves only a little with size. To grow, a brand has to win many more buyers. That includes people who buy it only once or twice a year.
It also says something about light buyers. Most of a brand's buyers buy it rarely. They are easy to ignore, because each one spends little. But there are so many of them that they add up to a big share of sales. A plan that talks only to loyal fans leaves them out.
The common mistake is to spend the budget on a loyalty scheme to grow a small brand. Points and rewards mostly reach people who would have bought anyway. They can help keep buyers. They rarely make a small brand big.
Worked example
A small cereal brand chases its fans
A cereal brand with 2% of the market spends a year on a loyalty app. Its 5,000 app users buy 10% more often. But total sales grow just 1%, because those users were a small slice of its buyers.
The next year it puts the money into wider ads and more shops. Sales grow 9%.
The words for this lesson1
Check yourself
Do small brands have more loyal buyers than big brands?
Finished this lesson?
Marking it complete also marks its 1 glossary entries learned, which updates your roadmap and your saved page. 0 are already marked.