Skip to content
BENIBIX Learn

Burden of Proof

General🤔 Critical ThinkingCritical Thinking Basics

Also known as Onus of Proof, Onus Probandi

Whoever makes a claim has to prove it. The one who doubts it does not.

Think of it like

It is like a game of show and tell. Whoever brings the claim has to show it.

Example

Jack says a lucky coin helps him pass tests. Lucy asks for proof. Jack replies that she cannot prove it does not, which shifts the burden the wrong way.

Why it matters

It stops anyone from winning an argument just by making a claim. It keeps debates fair.

Definition

The burden of proof is the duty to back up a claim. It falls on the person making the claim, not on the person doubting it. Saying you cannot prove me wrong is not proof. The bigger or stranger the claim, the more proof it needs. In court, the side that brings the case has to prove it.
Whoever states the conclusion has to supply the premises that hold it up.

Common mistake

Asking the doubter to disprove a claim. A claim with no proof does not need disproving.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Claimer proves. The one who claims must show it.
  2. 2
    Big claims need more. Strange claims need strong proof.
  3. 3
    No proof, no claim. Silence is not support.

Learn it properly