Premises and Conclusions
Level 1 · How an argument works
What an argument is made of, and the two questions that test it. Who has to prove a claim, and why the doubter does not.
Course contentsLesson 1 of 8
Level 1 · How an argument works
Level 2 · Logical fallacies
Level 3 · Evidence and sources
Level 4 · Tools for thinking
After this lesson you can
- Find the reasons and the claim in an argument
- Ask the two questions that test any argument
- Say who carries the burden of proof
10 mincovers 3 glossary entries
What is an argument made of?
An argument is a claim backed by reasons. The reasons are called premises, and the claim they support is the conclusion. Every argument can be tested with two questions. Are the premises true? And does the conclusion follow from them? If either answer is no, the argument fails, however sure it sounds.
In daily talk, an argument means a fight. In thinking, it means something calmer. A friend who says we should leave now, because the film starts at eight and the drive takes forty minutes, has made an argument. Two premises, one conclusion.
Critical thinking is the habit of asking those two questions before you agree. It is not being negative or doubting all you hear. It is checking the reasons and the proof for an idea, then deciding how much to believe it. Sometimes the answer is a firm yes.
The two questions catch different faults. A premise can be false: maybe the drive takes an hour. Or the premises can be true and still not lead to the claim. It rained, and I lost my keys, so rain makes me lose things. Each fact is fine. The link is not.
The burden of proof says that whoever makes a claim has to back it up. If someone says a pill cures colds, it is on them to show it. You do not have to prove that it does not. Doubting a claim is not a claim of its own.
The bigger the claim, the more proof it needs. A friend who says they had toast for breakfast needs none. A friend who says they saw a ghost needs a lot. Asking for proof is fair. Being asked to disprove something nobody has shown is not.
This course stops at reasoning. It covers how arguments are built, how they break and how to weigh proof. The biases built into the mind, such as seeing what we expect, are a separate subject. So are logic with symbols and the maths of statistics.
Worked example
Sam is sold a water filter
A seller tells Sam that tap water in his town has 40 harmful things in it, so he needs a $300 filter. Sam asks which 40, and where the number comes from.
The seller has no list. The town's own water report, free online, shows every test passed. The burden was on the seller, and he could not carry it.
The words for this lesson3
Check yourself
Someone says a pill cures colds. Who has to prove it?
Finished this lesson?
Marking it complete also marks its 3 glossary entries learned, which updates your roadmap and your saved page. 0 are already marked.