Skip to content
BENIBIX Learn

Systems and Contingency Theory

Level 3 Β· Modern theory

Two modern views from the 1960s. A firm is a set of linked parts in a wider world, and the right way to run it depends on the case.

Course contentsLesson 7 of 9

After this lesson you can

  • Describe a firm as an open system
  • Explain why there is no one best way
  • Tell a firm run on strict rules from a loose one

12 mincovers 2 glossary entries

Worth reading first: Maslow and Herzberg

Why there is no one best way

Two ideas from the 1960s changed how firms are studied. Systems theory sees a firm as linked parts inside a wider world, and Daniel Katz and Robert Kahn set it out for organizations in 1966. Contingency theory says there is no one best way to manage. A 1961 study by Tom Burns and George Stalker helped found it.

Systems theory says a firm takes in inputs, like people, money and materials. Its teams turn them into goods or services, which go out to the world. What comes back, like sales and complaints, changes what goes in next. A firm that ignores what comes back is closed to its world and falls behind.

The parts are linked, so a change in one moves the others. Cut the delivery team to save money, and late orders can cost more in lost sales than the saving. Many problems at work sit between teams, not inside one. A team can hit its own target while the whole firm does worse.

Burns and Stalker studied firms in Scotland and England, many of them in electronics. Some ran with strict rules, set jobs and orders from the top. They called these mechanistic. Others ran loosely, with jobs that shifted and ideas that flowed in every direction. They called these organic.

Neither kind won. Mechanistic firms did well in stable markets. Organic firms did well where the tech and the market kept changing. The right shape depended on the setting, which is the core of contingency theory.

Contingency theory is a direct answer to Taylor, Fayol and Weber, who each looked for one best way. It says the manager's job is to read the case and fit the approach to it. Size, tech, market and people all count.

The risk is using it as an excuse. Saying it depends is only useful when you say what it depends on. What is left of both ideas is used all the time. Look at the whole firm, and copy another firm's methods only if your case matches theirs.

Inputs come in, the firm's linked teams turn them into outputs, and feedback changes the next round.

Mechanistic and organic firms

MechanisticOrganic
JobsFixed and written downShift as the work changes
DecisionsMade at the topMade where the knowledge is
TalkUp and down the chainIn every direction
Best settingStable marketsFast-changing tech and markets

Worked example

One hospital, two styles

A hospital runs its emergency room on strict rules and quick orders. Each of its 40 staff knows exactly what to do when a patient arrives.

Its research lab, in the same building, runs loosely. Its 12 scientists pick their own projects and meet every week to swap ideas. Both work, because each fits its setting.

The words for this lesson2

Check yourself

Did strict firms or loose firms do better in Burns and Stalker's study?

Finished this lesson?

Marking it complete also marks its 2 glossary entries learned, which updates your roadmap and your saved page. 0 are already marked.