Skip to content
BENIBIX Learn

Theory X, Y and Z

Level 2 Β· The people side

Two views of workers from Douglas McGregor in 1960, and a third, quite different theory from William Ouchi in 1981. How a boss's beliefs come true.

Course contentsLesson 5 of 9

After this lesson you can

  • Tell Theory X from Theory Y
  • Explain how a boss's belief comes true
  • Say what Theory Z adds, and who wrote it

12 mincovers 2 glossary entries

Worth reading first: Hawthorne Studies

How a boss's beliefs shape the team

Theory X and Theory Y are two views a manager can hold about workers. Douglas McGregor, a professor at MIT, set them out in his 1960 book The Human Side of Enterprise. Theory X says people avoid work and must be pushed. Theory Y says people can enjoy work and lead themselves.

A Theory X boss sets tight rules, checks often and uses rewards and threats. A Theory Y boss sets the goal, gives people room and trusts them to plan the work. McGregor was not describing two kinds of workers. He was describing two kinds of belief inside managers' heads.

His key point is that each belief tends to come true. Treat people as lazy, and they do the least they must, which seems to prove the boss right. Treat them as able, and many rise to it. The rules a boss writes shape the people who live under them.

Theory Z is another idea by another author. William Ouchi, a US professor, wrote it up in 1981. Japanese firms were winning in many markets then. He put the usual US firm beside the usual Japanese one and set out a mix of the two.

A Theory Z firm keeps people for a long time and moves them through many parts of the firm. Big choices are agreed as a group. But unlike the typical Japanese firm, one named person still owns each result. Promotion is slow, and trust counts for more than rules.

The common mix-up is to think McGregor wrote all three. He wrote X and Y. Ouchi added Z about twenty years later, and he was answering a different question: what can firms learn from each other's countries?

What is left is the habit of asking what a workplace thinks of its people, since the rules give it away. The jobs for life in Theory Z have faded in many places. Its point that trust over many years helps both sides has not.

Each belief shapes the rules, and the rules shape how people act.
Theory Z takes long jobs and group choices from the Japanese firm. It keeps one owner for each result from the US firm.

Worked example

Lucy drops the log-in checks

Lucy's new team of 7 has its log-in times checked every day, and people leave at 5 on the dot. She stops the checks and sets 3 clear goals for the month instead.

Within two months, the team plans its own week, and two people offer to train new staff. Nothing about the people changed, only the rules.

The words for this lesson2

Check yourself

Who wrote Theory Z?

Finished this lesson?

Marking it complete also marks its 2 glossary entries learned, which updates your roadmap and your saved page. 0 are already marked.