Select Menus and Pickers
Level 2 · Getting answers in
How the length of a list picks the control. Segmented controls, select menus and comboboxes, plus sliders, steppers and date pickers.
Course contentsLesson 6 of 14
Level 1 · Parts and their states
Level 2 · Getting answers in
Level 3 · Finding your way
Level 4 · Layers, messages and waiting
Level 5 · Showing many things
After this lesson you can
- Match a picker to the length of a list
- Choose a slider or a number stepper
- Use a date picker where it helps
11 mincovers 6 glossary entries
Worth reading first: Checkbox vs Toggle Switch
How long the list is decides the control
The number of choices decides which picker to use. Under about six, show them all at once, as radio buttons or a segmented control. From six to about thirty, fold them into a select menu that opens when pressed. Past thirty, nobody wants to scroll, so let people type to find their choice.
A segmented control is a row of joined buttons where one is always picked, like Day, Week and Month on a calendar. It is quick, because every choice is in plain sight. It only fits a few short labels, so it suits a view switch rather than a long form.
A select menu is a closed box that opens into a list. Pick one value, and the list folds away again. It saves room on a form. The cost is that people cannot see the choices until they open it, so do not hide two or three options this way.
A combobox is a text box joined to a list. Type a few letters, and the list shrinks to the matches. Lon finds London. It is the right tool for a country, a city or a product from a long catalog, where scrolling would take far too long.
A slider is a handle you drag along a line. It is good when the exact number matters less than the feel, like how loud or how bright. A number stepper is a number with minus and plus buttons, each press adding or taking away one. It suits small counts, like the number of guests.
A date picker is a small calendar where you tap a day instead of typing it. It helps for dates near today, such as booking a table next week. For a date of birth, it is slow, because the user has to page back through years. Three short boxes for day, month and year are faster.
The common mistake is to put every choice in a select menu out of habit. A menu with two options, Yes and No, makes people tap twice to see what one glance would show. Use the list length as your guide, not habit.
Drag the list length
Drag the list length. At six the choices close into a box, and past thirty you have to type.
As the list grows, the control changes. Short lists stay open, longer ones fold into a box, and very long ones ask you to type.
Which picker fits which job
| Control | Best for | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Segmented control | 2 to 5 short choices | Day, Week, Month |
| Select menu | About 6 to 30 choices | Shirt size |
| Combobox | A long list to search | Country or city |
| Slider | A rough amount | Volume |
| Number stepper | A small exact count | Number of guests |
Worked example
A travel site fixes its country list
A travel site asked for each guest's country in a select menu. The list held 195 countries. On a phone, picking Portugal took about 15 seconds of scrolling.
The team made it a combobox. Typing Por brought Portugal to the top. The same task now took about 3 seconds.
The words for this lesson6
Check yourself
What is the best control for picking one country from a list of almost 200?
Finished this lesson?
Marking it complete also marks its 6 glossary entries learned, which updates your roadmap and your saved page. 0 are already marked.