Spinners and Skeleton Screens
Level 4 · Layers, messages and waiting
The signs that say an app is busy. What you know about the wait picks the sign: nothing, a spinner, a progress bar or a skeleton screen.
Course contentsLesson 12 of 14
Level 1 · Parts and their states
Level 2 · Getting answers in
Level 3 · Finding your way
Level 4 · Layers, messages and waiting
Level 5 · Showing many things
After this lesson you can
- Match a loading sign to the wait
- Use a progress bar for long tasks
- Explain what a skeleton screen shows
10 mincovers 3 glossary entries
Worth reading first: Toast and Alert Messages
What you know about the wait picks the sign
The right loading sign depends on what you know about the wait. Under about a tenth of a second, a wait feels instant and needs no sign. Around one second, people notice but keep their flow. Past about ten seconds, they start to drift away. Each length of wait calls for a different sign.
A spinner is a small turning circle that says the app is busy. It says nothing about how long. That is fine for a wait of a second or a few. For anything longer, a spinner alone leaves people wondering whether the app has frozen.
A progress bar fills up to show how much of a task is done. It is the right sign for a long task, such as uploading a 2 gigabyte video. People will wait much longer when they can see the end coming. The bar should move steadily, not sit at 99 percent for a minute.
A skeleton screen is a gray outline of the page, shown while the real content loads. Boxes stand where the photos will go and bars where the text will go. It tells people what kind of page is coming and where to look. The real content then fills the shapes in.
A skeleton also makes a page feel faster, even when it is not. Nothing jumps around when the content arrives, because the space was already kept for it. A page that loads in bits and shoves the text down each time feels slow and hard to read.
Do not show a sign for a very short wait. A spinner that flashes up for a tenth of a second is worse than none, because it looks like a flicker. Many apps wait a short moment before showing any sign at all.
The common mistake is a spinner for everything. A spinner on a long upload tells people nothing about when it will end. If you know how much is done, show a progress bar. If you know the shape of the page, show a skeleton.
Pick what you know
A spinner is the kettle: on, and silent about when.
Pick what you know about the wait, then run it. The sign follows from the knowledge.
Choose what you know about the wait, then run it. The sign follows from that choice.
Which sign for which wait
| What you know | The sign | Example |
|---|---|---|
| It is nearly instant | No sign at all | Ticking a box |
| Only that it started | Spinner | Sending a message |
| How much is done | Progress bar | Uploading a video |
| The shape of the page | Skeleton screen | Opening a news feed |
Worked example
A video site shows the upload
A video site showed a spinner while a file uploaded. Big files took 5 minutes. Many users closed the tab because they thought it had frozen.
The team swapped the spinner for a progress bar with a percent. Fewer uploads were cancelled, though the speed did not change at all.
The words for this lesson3
Check yourself
Which loading sign fits a 5 minute file upload?
Finished this lesson?
Marking it complete also marks its 3 glossary entries learned, which updates your roadmap and your saved page. 0 are already marked.