Skip to content
BENIBIX Learn

Circular Reasoning

General🤔 Critical ThinkingErrors in Reasoning

Also known as Circular Argument, Begging the Question, Petitio Principii

The claim is used as its own proof. So it goes round and round.

Think of it like

It is like a dog chasing its own tail. It runs and runs, but gets nowhere.

Example

Jack says his favourite band is the best in the world. Asked why, he says it is because no band is better.

Why it matters

It can sound convincing because the words change. Spotting it saves time spent on an argument that has no proof inside it.

Definition

Circular reasoning is using the claim itself as the reason to believe it. The argument ends where it began. Often the claim is just said again in other words, so it sounds like a reason. Nothing new has been shown. The formal name for it is begging the question.
Top right: the claim loops back to prove itself.

Common mistake

Using begging the question to mean raising the question. In logic it means assuming the answer.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Claim as reason. The proof is the claim again.
  2. 2
    New words, same idea. A restatement hides the loop.
  3. 3
    Ask for outside proof. Look for a reason that is not the claim.

Learn it properly