Slippery Slope Fallacy
Level 2 · Logical fallacies
Four ways the link from reasons to claim breaks. A chain of feared steps, a claim that proves itself, too few cases, and after so because.
Course contentsLesson 5 of 8
Level 1 · How an argument works
Level 2 · Logical fallacies
Level 3 · Evidence and sources
Level 4 · Tools for thinking
After this lesson you can
- Ask for proof of each link in a slippery slope
- Spot a claim used as its own reason
- Explain why one thing after another is not cause
12 mincovers 4 glossary entries
Worth reading first: Logical Fallacies
Why does one step not always lead to the next?
Some fallacies keep to the point but break the link from reasons to claim. A slippery slope says one small step will lead to disaster, with no proof of the steps between. Circular Reasoning uses the claim as its own proof. A hasty generalization draws a big rule from too few cases. The post hoc fallacy treats one thing after another as cause.
The slippery slope sounds like a warning. If we allow phones at lunch, next they will use them in class, then nobody will learn. Each link might happen. The fallacy is assuming they all will, with no reason given for any of them. Ask for proof of each step.
Some slopes are real. One drink can lead to another, and small debts can grow. The difference is evidence. A real slope can show why each step makes the next more likely. A fallacy just lines up scary steps and hopes nobody checks.
Circular Reasoning goes round in a loop. This book is true because it says it is true. You can trust me because I am honest. The reason given is just the claim in new words. It feels like proof, but nothing outside the loop holds it up.
A hasty generalization jumps from a few cases to everyone. Two rude waiters in one city, so people there are rude. It is induction with far too few cases, or cases that are not typical. The fix is to ask how many cases, and how they were picked.
The post hoc fallacy comes from the Latin for after this, so because of this. The rooster crows, then the sun rises. I wore my lucky socks and we won. Two things in a row is not proof that the first caused the second. Many things happen before any event.
Post hoc is behind many health myths. People take a remedy when a cold is at its worst. A few days later they feel better, as they would have anyway. The remedy gets the credit. A fair test needs a group that did not take it.
Worked example
Ben's lucky shirt
Ben wore a red shirt to three football games, and his team won all three. He decides the shirt brings luck.
Over the season he wears it to 10 games and they win 5. Without it they win 5 of 10 as well. Three wins in a row was too few to judge.
The words for this lesson4
Check yourself
I took a remedy and felt better in three days. Why is that not proof it worked?
Finished this lesson?
Marking it complete also marks its 4 glossary entries learned, which updates your roadmap and your saved page. 0 are already marked.