Conformity and Groupthink
Level 4 · Groups and influence
Why people give answers they know are wrong to match a group. Why popular things get more popular. How a team can agree its way into a mistake.
Course contentsLesson 8 of 14
Level 1 · How we judge
Level 2 · How we choose
Level 3 · Ourselves and others
Level 4 · Groups and influence
Level 5 · What drives us
Level 6 · How people differ
After this lesson you can
- Say what the line study found about going along
- Spot the bandwagon effect
- Name ways a team can avoid groupthink
12 mincovers 3 glossary entries
Worth reading first: Stereotypes and Prejudice
Why do people go along with the group?
Conformity is changing what you say or do to match the group. In the 1950s, people were asked which of three lines matched a fourth. The answer was obvious. But when everyone else in the room, all actors, gave the same wrong answer, real subjects went along about a third of the time. About three in four went along at least once.
When just one other person in the room gave the right answer, going along dropped sharply. One ally makes speaking up much easier. That is a useful fact for anyone who disagrees in a meeting.
The bandwagon effect is picking something just because lots of other people did. A queue outside a cafe draws a bigger queue. A song climbs a chart because it is on the chart. Being liked becomes its own reason, good or not.
Groupthink is when a group wants to agree so much that it stops thinking well. Doubts go unsaid, outside views are brushed off, and the plan looks safer than it is. The idea was named in the early 1970s from studies of failed government plans, where clever teams agreed on bad calls.
Groupthink is most likely when a team is close, under pressure, and led by someone whose view is known from the start. Each person takes the silence to mean that all agree. Often, several people had the same doubt and kept it to themselves.
Teams can guard against it. The leader speaks last. One person is asked to argue against the plan. People write their views down before anyone talks. Outsiders review the decision. Each of these makes room for the doubt that would otherwise stay quiet.
Going along is not always wrong. Often the group knows something you do not. The trouble starts when you go along against your own clear evidence, or when nobody checks whether the group is right.
Worked example
A launch nobody doubted out loud
A team of 8 agrees to launch a product in 6 weeks. Afterwards, an anonymous survey shows 5 of them thought it needed 12.
For the next launch, each person writes down a date before the meeting. The guesses range from 5 to 14 weeks, and the team settles on 10.
The words for this lesson3
Check yourself
In the line study, what made people stop going along with a wrong answer?
Finished this lesson?
Marking it complete also marks its 3 glossary entries learned, which updates your roadmap and your saved page. 0 are already marked.