Milgram Experiment
Level 4 · Groups and influence
The famous study of orders, and the prison study that proved weaker than it looked. Plus the $1 study that showed how we change our minds to fit what we did.
Course contentsLesson 10 of 14
Level 1 · How we judge
Level 2 · How we choose
Level 3 · Ourselves and others
Level 4 · Groups and influence
Level 5 · What drives us
Level 6 · How people differ
After this lesson you can
- Say what the Milgram Experiment found
- Say why the prison study is weak proof
- Explain cognitive dissonance with the $1 study
12 mincovers 3 glossary entries
Worth reading first: The Bystander Effect
What did the most famous psychology experiments really show?
The Milgram Experiment, in the early 1960s, tested how far people would obey orders to hurt someone. People were told to give shocks to a learner, rising from 15 to 450 volts. The learner was an actor and the shocks were fake. In the best-known version, 26 of 40 people went all the way to 450 volts.
The people who obeyed were not cruel. Many sweated, laughed nervously and begged to stop. But a calm man in a lab coat kept saying the study must go on. Later versions showed obedience fell when the man was not in the room, or when others refused.
The Stanford Prison Experiment in 1971 put students in the roles of guards and prisoners in a fake jail. It was planned for 14 days and stopped after 6, as guards grew harsh. For decades it was taught as proof that roles make people cruel.
Later research found serious problems. The guards had been coached to be tough, and some said they were acting. It was one small group, with no comparison group. Today it is seen as weak evidence. It is a good lesson in how a famous story can outrun its data.
Cognitive dissonance is the bad feeling when what you think and what you do do not match. In a 1959 study, people did a dull task, then were paid to tell the next person it was fun. Those paid $1 later rated the task as more fun than those paid $20.
The $20 group had a good reason to lie. The $1 group did not, so they eased the clash by changing their mind. The task must have been fun after all. People often change beliefs to fit what they already did, not the other way round.
The common mistake is to treat a famous study as settled. Some classic results hold up well in retests. Others shrink or vanish. Ask whether a finding has been repeated by other teams, with more people, before you build on it.
Worked example
Paul and his new phone
Paul spends $1,200 on a phone and then reads that a $500 one scores almost the same in tests. He feels uneasy.
Within a day he is telling friends the camera alone is worth the extra $700. He did not learn anything new about the camera.
The words for this lesson3
Check yourself
In the 1959 study, why did people paid $1 rate a dull task as more fun?
Finished this lesson?
Marking it complete also marks its 3 glossary entries learned, which updates your roadmap and your saved page. 0 are already marked.