The Bystander Effect
Level 4 · Groups and influence
Why people help less when more people are around. Why we try less hard in a group. Does being watched really change how we work?
Course contentsLesson 9 of 14
Level 1 · How we judge
Level 2 · How we choose
Level 3 · Ourselves and others
Level 4 · Groups and influence
Level 5 · What drives us
Level 6 · How people differ
After this lesson you can
- Explain why crowds help less
- Get help from one person in a crowd
- Spot social loafing in a team
11 mincovers 3 glossary entries
Worth reading first: Conformity and Groupthink
Why do people help less when others are around?
The bystander effect means people are less likely to help when more people are around. In a 1968 study, people heard someone have a seizure over an intercom. Alone, 85 in 100 went to help. When they thought four others could hear too, only 31 in 100 did.
Two things cause it. Responsibility spreads out, so each person feels it is someone else's job. And people look around to see if it is serious. If nobody else moves, each takes the calm faces as a sign that nothing is wrong.
The fix, if you need help in a crowd, is to pick one person. You in the blue coat, call an ambulance. That puts the whole job on one person and ends the waiting. Most people will help once they are asked directly.
Social loafing is putting in less effort in a group than you would alone. In studies where people pulled a rope or shouted, six people did far less than six times what one did. Some of the loss is poor timing. Much of it is people easing off when their own part cannot be seen.
It shrinks when each person's work can be seen, when the task matters to them, and when the group is small. Clear roles help more than pep talks. So does a group whose members care about each other.
The Hawthorne Effect is people acting in a new way because they know they are watched. It is named after a factory where output seemed to rise in the 1920s, whatever was changed. Even dimmer lights seemed to help. Later looks at the data found the effect was much weaker than the story.
Even so, being watched does change behavior in many studies. It is why good research hides what is being measured where it can, and compares groups that are watched equally. A change that only works while someone holds a clipboard is not a real change.
Worked example
A fall at the station
A man falls on a busy platform. Dozens of people slow down, but nobody stops for almost a minute.
Nina points at one man and says, you, please call for help, and asks a woman to bring water. Both do it at once, and a crowd now gathers to help.
The words for this lesson3
Check yourself
You need help in a crowd. What works best?
Finished this lesson?
Marking it complete also marks its 3 glossary entries learned, which updates your roadmap and your saved page. 0 are already marked.