Deductive vs Inductive Logic
Level 1 · How an argument works
The two main ways to reason, from a rule down to a case or from cases up to a rule. Why one gives certainty and the other only good odds.
Course contentsLesson 2 of 8
Level 1 · How an argument works
Level 2 · Logical fallacies
Level 3 · Evidence and sources
Level 4 · Tools for thinking
After this lesson you can
- Tell deductive from inductive reasoning
- Explain why induction can never be certain
- Rebuild a view you disagree with as a steel man
11 mincovers 3 glossary entries
Worth reading first: Premises and Conclusions
What is the difference between deductive and inductive reasoning?
Deductive reasoning goes from a rule to a sure answer about one case. Inductive reasoning goes from many cases to a likely rule. All birds have feathers. A robin is a bird. So a robin has feathers, and that is deduction. Every swan I have seen is white, so all swans are white. That is induction.
Deduction is airtight when it works. If the premises are true and the steps are right, the conclusion must be true. There is no room for doubt. The catch is that it only tells you what was already packed into the premises. It does not discover anything new.
Induction is how we learn about the world. Science, weather forecasts and your guess that the bus comes at nine all run on it. It can only ever be likely, never sure. People in Europe believed all swans were white, until black swans were found in Australia.
So the two are judged in different ways. A deductive argument is valid or not. An inductive one is strong or weak, and it gets stronger with more cases, more varied cases and no cases that break the rule. One good counter-case can sink it.
Most real reasoning mixes them. A doctor uses induction to learn that a symptom usually means a certain illness. Then she uses deduction: this patient has the symptom, so test for that illness. Each step is only as good as the one before it.
Good reasoning also means being fair to the other side. A steel man is the strongest version of a view you disagree with. You build it first, then reply to it. If your answer only works against a weak version, you have not answered the view at all.
The common mistake is to treat an inductive rule as if it were a deductive one. A pattern that has held a hundred times feels like a law. It is still a guess about the next case. Holding it a little loosely is not weakness. It is accuracy.
Which one you are using
- 1
Deductive
You start from a rule you accept and apply it to one case. If the rule is true, the answer must be.
- 2
Inductive
You start from cases you have seen and guess the rule. The more cases, the better the odds, but never a sure thing.
Worked example
Priya tests a new bus route
Priya takes the new 7:40 bus five days in a row, and it reaches work by 8:15 each time. She concludes it always will. That is induction.
On day six, roadworks add 25 minutes. Her rule was a good bet, not a promise, and she now leaves a ten-minute margin.
The words for this lesson3
Check yourself
Why can inductive reasoning never be certain?
Finished this lesson?
Marking it complete also marks its 3 glossary entries learned, which updates your roadmap and your saved page. 0 are already marked.