Logical Fallacies
Level 2 · Logical fallacies
What a logical fallacy is, and three of the most common. The straw man, the attack on the person, and the choice cut down to two.
Course contentsLesson 3 of 8
Level 1 · How an argument works
Level 2 · Logical fallacies
Level 3 · Evidence and sources
Level 4 · Tools for thinking
After this lesson you can
- Say what makes a mistake a fallacy
- Spot a straw man and an ad hominem
- Find the missing options in a false dilemma
11 mincovers 4 glossary entries
Worth reading first: Deductive vs Inductive Logic
What is a logical fallacy?
A logical fallacy is a mistake in how an argument is built. The argument may sound strong, and the conclusion may even be true, but the reasons do not support it. Fallacies have names because the same few tricks come up again and again. Naming one helps you see it.
The straw man twists what someone said into a weaker claim, then knocks that down. One person says kids should have a little less screen time. The reply is that banning all screens is mad. Nobody said ban. The real claim was never answered.
It works because the weak version is easy to beat, and the crowd may not notice the swap. The fix is to restate the other view before you answer it. Ask, is this what you mean? That is the steel man from the last level, used as a habit.
Ad hominem is Latin for to the person. It attacks the one making a claim instead of the claim. Why listen to her on taxes, she failed maths? Whether she failed maths says nothing about whether her point on taxes is right.
Not every remark about a person is a fallacy. If a witness was paid to say something, that bears on whether to trust them. The fallacy is using the person to dodge the reasons. The reasons are what is in doubt.
The false dilemma pretends there are only two choices when there are more. You are with us or against us. Either we cut the park or we raise taxes. Real choices often have a third road, or a mix of both, or a way to wait and learn more.
Knowing the names has a trap. Some people shout fallacy at every point they dislike and stop listening. A fallacy in one argument does not make its conclusion false. It only means that argument does not prove it. A better one might.
Worked example
A school board debate
Parent Tom asks the board to start school 30 minutes later. A board member replies that Tom wants kids to sleep all day and learn nothing.
That is a straw man. A second member says it is either the old time or no buses at all, a false dilemma. The board later finds a third plan that moves the bus times.
The words for this lesson4
Check yourself
If an argument has a fallacy in it, is its claim false?
Finished this lesson?
Marking it complete also marks its 4 glossary entries learned, which updates your roadmap and your saved page. 0 are already marked.